Get Inspired: 7 Best Turkey Sandwiches for Your Day After Thanksgiving Inspiration

If you're any bit of a self-respecting foodie, your favorite holiday is undoubtably right around the corner. 

No, we're not talking about the arrival of ol' Saint Nick or the eight gift-giving days of Hanukkah... we're talking about the most delicious, succulent, binge-worthy holiday of the year: Thanksgiving. 

Ok, ok, so the whole history of the holiday is pretty whacked and fantasized to glide over the pretty horrific massacre of the Native Americans that ensued for centuries thereafter, but it's also a time to give thanks for the bounty (however large or small) that we have today. 

We're insanely grateful for a particular feathery being that (when cooked) tastes like all of our holiday hopes and dreams have come true. 

That's right, eat your heart out vegans (or don't... because well, meat), turkey is what us omnivores are digging this particular holiday season. 

But what do you do when your stuck with a fridge full of uneaten roasted turkey after the food coma subsides post-Thanksgiving dinner? You make it into a deliciously awesome day-after-Thanksgiving turkey sandwich of course. 

Here is our list of amazing turkey sandwiches in NYC to find inspiration from.


1. Pretzel'd Gobbler from HBH Gourmet Sandwiches (407 Smith Street - Brooklyn)

hbhnyc Its a beautiful day out. Perfect weather for a turkey sandwich. Toasted pretzel bread, house smoked turkey, gruyere cheese, roasted peppers, caramelized onions, arugula and roasted garlic aioli. πŸ—πŸŒžπŸ”₯ #eeeeeats #sandwich #instagramwiches #eatingnyc #foodies #foodgasm #foodporn #fatboyproblems #fuckthatsdelicious #hungrygrls #brooklyn #cheflife #truecooks #chewyorkcity #newforkcity #carrollgardens #parkslope #gowanus #nyc #dumbo #redhook #myfab5


Now, most people load up their turkey sandwich with Thanksgiving leftovers. But you don't have to have the same old boring thing that everyone else has. You should take inspiration from HBH Gourmet Sandwiches and their "Pretzel'd Gobbler."

This baby has maple brined turkey breast, house smoked bacon, swiss cheese, tomato, baby arugula, and house made mayo on a pretzel roll. Everything is better with bacon. Add in a pretzel roll? We're stoked.


2. Spicy Rizzak from Tiny's Giant Sandwich Shop (129 Rivington Street)

thecaseymclain Spicy Rizzak


After your Thanksgiving food coma subsides, you probably want a variation on the meal, rather than piling up a sandwich with the meal itself. Try and take a page out of Tiny's Giant Sandwich Shop's book with their "Spicy Rizzak" sandwich. 

It's got sliced turkey, crispy bacon, melted cheddar, tomato, onion, and spicy chipotle mayo on a toasted sesame semolina hero. If you're lookin' to feel the heat, you need to try this sandwich. 


3. Middle Eastern Turkey Sandwich from Bite (211 East 14th Street)

bitenyc The perfect Saturday meal: the middle eastern turkey sandwich on multigrain bread! #bite #bitenyc #sandwich #turkey #middleeastern #healthy #delicious #amazing #lowfat #cafe #cool #fun #food #foodie #foodporn #foodofinstagram #photooftheday #picoftheday #instagood #instacool #love #like #nyc #ny #newyorkcity #newyork #unionsquare


Not all turkey sandwiches are created equal. Would you ever imagine putting hummus on your after-Thanksgiving turkey sandwich? No? Well, now you should. 

Check out the "Middle Eastern Turkey Sandwich" from Bite. It has smoked turkey, hummus, field greens, and plum tomatoes. 


4. Dirty Turkey from Court Street Grocers (various locations)

bobbypinapp Just died and went to lunch heaven @courtstgrocers. This place is amazing...yam and cheese, meatloaf sandwiches...and all sorts of cute groceries It's on our lunch spots near @coworkrs Gowanus map πŸ‘‰ https://www.bobbypin.co/p/5w8x8 #BobbyPinIt πŸ“


At Court Street Grocers, you have the option of a "Clean Turkey" sandwich or a "Dirty Turkey" sandwich. If you've read any of spoiled, you'll know that we're not going to pick a "clean" sandwich. 

The "Dirty Turkey" sandwich includes roasted turkey breast, chopped liver, chow-chow (a pickled relish), lettuce, red onion, and mayo on Sullivan Street Bakery "stecca doppio" bread. 

,

5. Thanksgiving Year-'round from Berkli Parc (63 Delancey Street)

berkliparc The "Thanksgiving Year-round!" A #slowroasted #turkey breast, #fresh #homemade #cranberrysauce, homemade turkey #stuffing, all on #balthazars #lavain.


Of course, we're not going to end our list without including a turkey sandwich complete with all of the Thanksgiving fixin's. 

The "Thanksgiving year-round" from Berkli Parc includes house-roasted turkey breast, homemade herbed stuffing, homemade cranberry sauce, alfalfa sprouts, and may on levain. Basically, it's all of our Thanksgiving prayers answered. 


6. Elena's Smoked Turkey Sandwich - The Original Sandwich Shoppe of New York (58 Greenwich Avenue)

esspeer Yes it's just a sandwich....but it's the best damn sandwich ever! πŸ΄πŸ˜‹πŸ‘πŸ½


Turkey really doesn't have to be boring. It also doesn't have to have the same ole Thanksgiving sides. It can be cheesy and delicious. 

Check out "Elena's Smoked Turkey Sandwich" with smoked turkey and melted mozzarella on a semolina baguette with homemade herbal mayo, lettuce and tomato. 


7. Grandpa from Mile End Deli (various locations)

krburr His name, The Grandpa #sandwichgoals Smoked Turkey, Rillettes, Pickles, Mustard, Rye


When you think about roasted turkey sandwiches, you probably have memories of your Grandpa in the kitchen, loading up some sliced bread with a slab of turkey breast, cold stuffing, and canned cranberry sauce. At least, we do.

This turkey sandwich would put your Grandpa's to shame. It's got smoked turkey, rillettes, pickles, and mustard on rye. You definitely do not need to be a grandparent to enjoy this sandwich.

Check out 7 Best Spots to Stuff Your Face with Delicious Turkey in NYC

[Feature Image Courtesy Instagram]

get spoiled in your inbox

recent