San Gennaro Fest in Little Italy is in full swing!
Last week, we let you in on the spots we'd hit in Little Italy if we were you.
However, we're sure some of you didn't take our advice (boo, you), and went to some of these overrated food joints for lackluster food at a premium price.
Since you already went to Little Italy and messed up by eating at these tourist traps, we've put together where you should've (and still can) go instead.
1. Overrated Pizza: Lombardi's (32 Spring Street)
While Lombardi's was the first pizzeria in the country, it's been coasting on that reputation for far too long. It may be the first, but it's certainly not the best.
We mainly make that statement due to the price of the pies. A large pizza will cost you $20.50. Want topping? That'll be an extra $3.00 per.
Unless that pizza is made of gold, it's a hard pass for us.
Instead: Roberta's (261 Moore Street - Brooklyn)
This place certainly doesn't coast on reputation, and instead proves its worth with flavor and quality.
The graffitied walls and laid back atmosphere is a far cry from Little Italy's hustle and bustle.
With the option of sitting indoors or outdoors or in the comfort of your own home (they deliver), there's no excuse to eat crappy, overpriced tourist bait instead of Roberta's.
2. Overrated Cannolis: Caffe Palmero (148 Mulberry Street)
This self-proclaimed "Cannoli King of Little Italy," may potentially have rights to that title in Little Italy, but the best cannolis in NYC lay beyond the boundaries of this microcosm.
If you claim that you are the "Cannoli King," those cannolis should blow away our tastebuds and change outlooks on life.
However, Caffe Palmero's cannolis are just meh. Maybe worth the title of Lord or Knight, but certainly no King.
Instead: Circo's Pastry Shop (312 Knickerbocker Avenue - Brooklyn)
Circo's could very easily dethrone Caffe Palmero as the "Cannoli King of NYC," because it certainly lives up to this title more than Caffe Palmero could ever dream.
Not only are the exteriors crisp and crunch, the interior is creamy with the perfect balance of sweetness and tang. It's worth the trip out to Brooklyn just for one of these cannolis.
3. Overrated Date Night: Da Nico (164 Mulberry Street)
In spite of being hyped up by Mayor Giuliani, Da Nico's falls flat. While it may have once been the incredibly authentic Italian joint that served NY's elite, it has since fallen from grace.
All too often, restaurants are hyped up to the point where they rely far too much on word of mouth and reputation, and then let their standards slip. Da Nico's falls into that category.
Instead: Roberto's Restaurant (603 Crescent Avenue - the Bronx)
fordhamfoodie Lettuce celebrate #LaborDay with salad, pasta, and wine β€οΈ Buttermilk Burrata over Arugula with Capers, Cherry Tomatoes, and a Balsamic Vinaigrette π·π·π· in Little Italy #fordhamfoodie
If you're looking for the kitschy atmosphere of many Little Italy restaurants, you will not find it here, and in our opinion, that's a good thing.
Instead, you'll be delighted by the incredibly authentic Italian cuisine. If you're looking for a place to wine and dine your significant other, this place has that old-world Italian charm that's sure to please.
,4. Overrated Service: Grotta Azzura (177 Mulberry Street)
While you'll most likely have a pretty decent meal at Grotta Azzura, the service may ruin your experience.
Like most restaurants in Little Italy, an automatic 20% gratuity charge is added to your final bill. Unfortunately, this practice is a turn off for most Manhattanites, particularly due to the expanse of excellent establishments at our fingertips.
Instead: Vite Vinosteria (31-05 34th Street - Astoria)
Along with top quality food, the attentive service at Vite Vinosteria sets it apart.
On top of their excellent service, it's dim, romantic atmosphere makes it a great spot for a dinner with your special someone.
5. Overrated Bakery: Ferrara's Bakery (195 Grand Street)
Ferrara's has been a staple in Little Italy since 1892, boasting that it is "New York's Famous Italian Bakery."
We don't disagree. But we'll let you in on a secret- there are so many other Italian bakeries in this city that are just as worth that title where you can skip the lines and inflated prices.
Instead: Veniero's Pastry Shop (342 East 11th Street)
flohee_yoon 121λ λ μΌμ΅μ§ π 2λ λ§μ λ μλ κ·Έ λ§μ κ·Έλλ‘μΌ! #μ΄ν리μμΉμ¦μΌμ΅ #κ³ΌμΌνλ₯΄νΈ #veniero's #λ΄μ #μ¬ν #λμ νΈ #μΆμ΅νμ΄
Just like Ferrara's, Veniero's pastries deliver in the flavor and authenticity department. Their lobster tails and cheesecakes are customer favorites.
Although the bakery is on the Lower East Side, it offers all of the quality and flavor of an Italian bakery in Little Italy.
On top of the traditional favorites, Veniero's offers creative and seasonal options like pumpkin pie.
6. Overrated Restaurant: La Mela (167 Mulberry Street)
Dining at La Mela can be hit or miss. There are times that the food and service are excellent and worth the price, but other times where you will be sent home hungry and poor.
Instead of taking your chances with a tourist trap that has inconsistent food and service, try for a restaurant outside of Little Italy.
Instead: Pepolino Restaurant (281 West Broadway)
Pepolino is a must for anyone who is even remotely interested in Italian cuisine.
This quaint restaurant has slowly been increasing in popularity due to its authentic, flavorful dishes and homey atmosphere.
You may even forget you're not in Florence while you're dining at Pepolino.
Don't get caught in a trap! Check out 7 More Authentic Alternatives to Overrated Activities in NYC.

