It's So Nice to Finally "Meat" You: 11 Juiciest NYC Burgers You Just Gotta Sink Your Teeth Into ASAP

Hey New York City, did you know May is National Burger Month?

Now that you're in the know, that leaves you with a pretty good excuse to chow down on the city's best burgers for the entire month of May, and we're talking more about just Shake Shack here.

Of course, as true New Yorkers, we do love us some Shake Shack, but there's definitely more to burgers in this city than just that.

We love our burgers thick and juicy, covered in melted cheese and lots of other hot and cold goodies and we bet you do too.

Here are 11 of the juiciest burger joints you just have to sink your teeth into this month during National Burger Month!


1. 5 Napkin Burger (various NYC locations)

5napkinburger The myth, the legend. 📸: @allisonkimchi


Find a 5 Napkin anywhere in the city and sit down with the Original 5 Napkin Burger, because you could get a plain old cheeseburger anywhere else.

This bad boy is made of ten solid ounces of fresh ground chuck and then finished off with gruyere cheese, a mountain of sauteed onions, and rosemary aioli.

Dare I say, you might even need six napkins to fix yourself up after you eat this...


2. The Spotted Pig (314 West 11th Street)

sultannyc #spottedpig #burger #nyc #picoftheday #photooftheday #instagood #instadaily #food #foodporn #foodpics


We'll bet you're used to Irish pubs all around the city, but have you ever set foot inside a British restaurant? That's what the Spotted Pig is serving up, and one of the most notable menu items is their chargrilled burger.

A patty made from a blend of brisket, rump, and chuck is topped with quality Roquefort blue cheese, and the bun is grilled lightly to complete that chargrilled perfection.

And let's not forget that hearty mount of perfectly crisp, lightly salted shoestring fries that comes along with it. Yep, this one's definitely a showstopper in the NYC burger scene.


3. Minetta Tavern (113 Macdougal Street)

premii6109 Made with @nocrop_rc #rcnocrop #newyorkcity #manhattan #minetatavern #blacklabelburger Great burger but expensive!


This stunning French cafe in Greenwich Village could charm the pants off of you Parisienne style, but we think that if you come by and get the Black Label Burger, you'll experience...love at first bite. *wink*

The Black Label Burger is made of premium dry-aged cuts of beef topped with caramelized onions on a sesame bun plus a lovely side of pommes frites.

It doesn't come with cheese, but when you've got high caliber meats in your burger, something tells us you won't be missing it.


4. Burger and Barrel (25 West Houston Street)

burgerandbarrel Come visit us this week before we take the Mangalitsa #Pork #Burger off the menu #DoubleBacon #Goodbye


This trendy SoHo eatery is known for its burgers that are sleek, classic, and downright delicious.

The Bash Burger is a delicious standout at Burger and Barrel, with old-school flair like American cheese and pickles made unique with prize-winning bacon and onion jam.

Oh, and this burger comes with fries AND onion rings! Double the fun, right?


5. The Counter (7 Times Square)

brooke_b_fit NO CAPTION NECESSARY! 😍😋🍳🍔 #thecounter #thecounterburger #buildyourown #yolkporn #burgerporn #gourmetburger #somuchhappiness #baconeggcheese #burgerperfection #eggcellent


Everyone loves their burger a certain way, right? At The Counter, they appreciate that privilege and let you do burgers your own way.

At The Counter, your order is in the form of a paper checklist where you can pick the kind of burger you want, down to the sauce, toppings, cheese, and bun.

Customizing something has never been so delicious as it is here.


6. Paul's Da Burger Joint (131 2nd Avenue)

paulsdaburgerjoint #MeatlesMonday? ....we got you. #VeggieBurger A good meal can diminish that #ManicMonday feeling. GET 20% OFF WHEN YOU SPEND $20. When Ordering from: paulsburgersnyc.com Promo Code: FB20 #paulsdaburgerjoint #NYCBURGER #BURGERJOINT #PaulsDaBurgerJoint #vegan #veganporn #nycfood #Vegetarian


It's hard out here for a Jersey girl like me looking to get my diner fix in the big city.

As you well may know, diners are known for having some of the most exceptional burgers for low, low prices, and Paul's Da Burger Joint in the East Village is no exception.

These burgers are real-deal thick and moist through and through, making for one beefy, juicy bite. With a nice variety of cheesy toppings and delicious finishing touches, this is a good way to get yourself a great burger without dropping bank.

,,

7. Whitmans (406 East 9th Street)

whitmansnyc We're open for lunch today! #thursdayvibes #burgerlife #peanutbutterbaconburger P B & B 🍔 Thanks for the love @bun_intended #LoveYourFamily #eeeeeats ❤️✨


Even though this is NYC, you can always get a taste of what real food is like across the country! Check out the Midwestern classic, the famous Juicy Lucy at Whitmans and you'll see what I'm talking about.

Juicy Lucy is a burger beauty with pimento cheese stuffed inside the short-rib blend burger (what a twist!) plus the usual suspects of lettuce, tomato, caramelized onions, spicy pickles, and a secret special sauce.

Oh, and watch out for that oozing hot cheese bursting at the center!


8. Joy Burger Bar (various NYC locations)

joyburgerbar #Yelper Fabien L calls this one the #EverythingBurger! What would you call yours? #burgersandfries #bestburger #instafood #foodporn #nyceats #eatingnyc #EatFamous #eeeeeats #burgerlovers #uppereastside #burgers 🍔 #fries 🍟 #joy 🌞 #JoyBurgerBar #EastHarlem 🌇


From the UES to the West Village, Joy Burger Bar brings hearty, made your way burgers to NYC.

You can choose your size and your meat and of course your toppings, so a burger from Joy can be as hulking or as petite as you need it to be.

Just don't spare yourself any extravagance, as these are burgers that you should truly indulge on.


9. Black Iron Burger (various NYC locations)

autumnspring5 #blackironburger #littleitalyburger #delicious #burger #food


Looking for no frills and badass burgers?

Check out Black Iron Burger, where the name of the game is cash only and you sit on barstools while you munch on your burger.

Go for the Masterpiece Burger. It's a double swiss cheeseburger with onions, bacon, and a jewel of a fried egg.

Yeah, it's basically your brunch on a burger, but if there's anything that's irresistible about eating burgers, it's breaking that egg yolk and letting it merge with that savory meaty flavor.


10. Royale (157 Avenue C)

burger One of NYC's most underrated. Eat a @royalebar #🍔 this weekend. #EEEEEATS 📷: @mealsandreels


Serving up the classic All-American burger in Alphabet City, Royale has burgers that are truly regal in taste.

It's a pretty standard burger here: pickles, cheese, tomatoes, white onion, and lettuce on an angus beef patty on a sesame seed brioche bun. You'll get a great burger without the fancy allure of exotic toppings, but the taste will be on par with even the frilliest of burgers.


11. Burger Bistro (various NYC locations)

bklyn_foodie The top one - Turkey Burger with Swiss, Carmalized Onions, Crumbled Bacon, Guacamole, lettuce & tomato on a Whole Wheat Bun 👌 Bottom - Turkey Burger with Mozzarella Cheese, Tomato, Carmalized Onions, Fried Egg & Guacamole 👌 #foodporn #BrooklynFoodie #BayRidge #brooklyn #burgerbistro #nyceats #peepmyeats #brooklyn #newyorkcity


Home of that outrageous Donut Burger, Burger Bistro has locations that stretch across Manhattan and Brooklyn. They'll let you do burgers your own way, which is always a great option to have.

Keep your eyes open for their daily and weekend specials because you never know what fabulously tasty burger concoction they're going to come up with next.

Love burgers? Shake Shack Set for West Coast Expansion; Will In-N-Out Burger Finally Come to NYC?

[Feature Image Courtesy Instagram] 

get spoiled in your inbox

recent